Is it ethical to clone animals and humans? | Argumentative Essay

Below written essay is an argumentative type of essay on the topic - Cloning of animals and humans. Add or remove paragraphs as per your requirement.

Cloning animals, the process of creating genetically identical copies of an organism, has been a topic of considerable debate since the successful cloning of Dolly the sheep in 1996. This breakthrough demonstrated the potential of cloning technology and sparked a global conversation about its ethical, scientific, and practical implications. As we delve into the practice of animal cloning, it is essential to examine both its potential benefits and the ethical challenges it presents.

Scientific Advancements and Benefits

One of the most significant benefits of animal cloning lies in its potential to advance scientific research. Cloning allows scientists to create genetically identical animals, providing consistent models for studying diseases, genetic conditions, and the effects of various treatments. This consistency is invaluable in medical research, where genetic variability can obscure experimental results. Cloning can also contribute to pharmaceutical development, as animals can be engineered to produce important drugs in their milk or blood, making production more efficient and scalable.

For Arguments

Medical Advancements: Cloning animals can lead to significant advancements in medical research by providing consistent and controlled models for studying diseases, genetic conditions, and testing new treatments.

Conservation of Endangered Species: Cloning can help preserve endangered species by increasing their population, ensuring genetic diversity, and preventing extinction. Cloning livestock can enhance food production by replicating animals with desirable traits such as higher milk yield, faster growth rates, or disease resistance.

Organ Transplants: Cloning humans could theoretically provide a source of organs for transplantation, reducing the shortage of organs and saving many lives.

Genetic Disease Prevention: Cloning could be used to eliminate hereditary genetic disorders by ensuring that embryos with genetic diseases are not brought to term.

Scientific Knowledge: Cloning research can enhance our understanding of genetics, embryonic development, and cellular differentiation, leading to broader scientific breakthroughs.

Pharmaceutical Production: Cloned animals can be engineered to produce pharmaceuticals, such as insulin or antibodies, in their milk, which can be more cost-effective and scalable.

Reviving Extinct Species: Cloning offers the possibility of bringing back extinct species, which can provide ecological and scientific benefits.

Reproductive Choice: For humans, cloning offers an additional reproductive choice for couples who cannot conceive naturally, potentially reducing the psychological burden of infertility.

Preservation of Genetic Material: Cloning can preserve the genetic material of exceptional individuals (both human and animal), potentially retaining important traits for future generations.

Improved Livestock Health: Cloning can create animals that are less susceptible to diseases, reducing the need for antibiotics and other medications.

Economic Benefits: Cloning can drive economic growth through biotechnology industries, creating jobs and generating revenue.

Reduction in Animal Testing: Cloning could reduce the need for large numbers of animals in research by providing genetically identical subjects, which can improve the consistency and reliability of experimental results.

Assistance for Research: Cloned animals with specific genetic modifications can aid in the study of gene functions and interactions, facilitating discoveries in genetics and biology.

Educational Tool: Cloning technology can be a powerful tool for education, helping to teach and inspire future generations of scientists about genetics, embryology, and biotechnology

Ethical Concerns and Animal Welfare

Despite these potential benefits, animal cloning raises several ethical concerns. One of the primary issues is animal welfare. Cloning often involves high failure rates and can result in developmental abnormalities, genetic defects, and premature aging in cloned animals. These health issues can lead to significant suffering, raising questions about the ethical treatment of cloned animals.

Against Arguments

Ethical Concerns: Many believe that cloning, especially of humans, is inherently unethical as it treats living beings as mere objects or commodities, undermining their dignity.

Identity and Individuality: Cloning humans raises profound questions about identity and individuality, potentially leading to psychological issues for clones who might struggle with their sense of self.

Animal Welfare: Cloning often involves high failure rates and can result in suffering for animals due to developmental issues, genetic defects, and premature aging.

Biodiversity Reduction: Reliance on cloning could reduce genetic diversity, making populations more vulnerable to diseases and environmental changes.

Exploitation Risks: Cloning could be exploited for unethical purposes, such as creating humans for specific tasks or traits, leading to potential abuse and exploitation.

Unpredictable Outcomes: Cloning is still a relatively new science with many unknowns, and the long-term health effects on clones are not fully understood.

Resource Intensive: Cloning is an expensive and resource-intensive process, which might divert funds from other important areas of scientific research and healthcare.

Moral Status of Clones: There is significant debate about the moral status of clones, particularly human clones, and whether they would have the same rights and status as naturally born individuals.

Potential for Misuse: Advances in cloning technology could lead to misuse by governments or organizations for coercive or unethical purposes, such as creating armies or exploiting individuals.

Religious Objections: Many religious groups oppose cloning on the grounds that it interferes with natural processes and the role of a higher power in creation.

Public Acceptance: There is significant public resistance to cloning, and societal acceptance is crucial for the successful integration of any new technology.

Ethical Slippery Slope: Allowing cloning could lead to a slippery slope of further genetic manipulation and eugenics, where the line between acceptable and unacceptable genetic modifications becomes blurred.

Unintended Consequences: The potential for unforeseen and unintended consequences, both biological and social, is high, and the risks may outweigh the benefits.

Legal and Regulatory Issues: Establishing effective legal and regulatory frameworks for cloning is challenging, and there are significant concerns about oversight and governance.

Impact on Natural Reproduction: Cloning might impact perceptions and practices related to natural reproduction, potentially leading to a devaluation of traditional family structures and relationships.
Societal and Environmental Impact

The societal implications of animal cloning are also significant. The practice could alter perceptions of natural reproduction and the value of individual animals, potentially leading to the commodification of life. Furthermore, the high costs associated with cloning might divert resources from other important areas of scientific research and environmental conservation.

From an environmental perspective, cloning might offer solutions to some problems but could also exacerbate others. For example, cloning could help restore populations of endangered species but might also lead to unintended ecological consequences if these populations become over-reliant on human intervention for survival.


In conclusion, the cloning of animals presents a complex interplay of scientific possibilities and ethical dilemmas. While it holds promise for advancing medical research, improving agricultural productivity, and aiding conservation efforts, it also raises significant concerns about animal welfare, genetic diversity, and societal impacts. As cloning technology continues to evolve, it is crucial to approach its application with caution, ensuring that ethical considerations are at the forefront of any decision-making process. Balancing the potential benefits with the moral and ecological risks will be essential in determining the future role of cloning in our society.

Post a Comment